View Article  Robert L. Hirsch "The Impending World Energy Mess"

ISBN 978-1926837-11-6. "The Impending World Energy Mess - what it is and what it means to YOU!" written by Robert L Hirsch, Roger H Bezdek and Robert M Wendling and published by Apogee Prime in 2010. The review copy is a first edition but is a paperback with dustcover (unusual!). For your money you get 251 pages boasting Preface, Foreword by James Schlesinger, Introduction, eighteen chapters, Postscript, References and Index. Those of us who have been following the peak oil story for a few years (about seven years in the reviewer's case) will be familiar with the work of this writing team. They were responsible for a 2005 report for the US Department of Energy called "Peaking of World Oil Production: Impacts, Mitigation & Risk Management". In it the team developed scenarios for crash programs to mitigate the risks arising from peak oil. They famously concluded that it would take around 20 years to adjust to peak oil hence we had better start earlier rather than later. Of course nothing happened. The report was of little interest to the US DOE. They buried it and it took a subsequent Freedom on Information request for it to emerge in to the public domain. The report has become a legend in its own lunchtime - so much so that it has become one of the corner stones of peakist folklore. Between the work of Richard Heinberg and Colin Campbell we had all we needed to launch a million paranoia's. From it the entire Transition movement was born as well as Post-Carbon Living.

However, one has to wonder: just how many of us ever read this report or know much about these authors? Well, you can read the 2005 report here. As for the authors, they are all highly qualified and have ...   more »

View Article  Ha-Joon Chang "23 Things They Don't Tell You About Capitalism"

Ha-Joon Chang "23 Things..."ISBN 978-1-846-14328-1. "23 things they don't tell you about Capitalism" by Ha-Joon Chang was published in 2010 by Penguin. This hardback has 286 pages with Acknowledgements, Introduction, twenty-three "things" as Chapters, a Conclusion, Notes and an Index. "This book is not an anti-capitalist manifesto" states the author right up front. This is probably a good thing as we probably wouldn't have it on our pages if it was. This is a follow up to Chang's successful 2007 book "Bad Samaritans" which we also reviewed here as a timely reminder (since the crash of 2008) of just how far neo-conservative economic dogma has held us back from building a sustainable economic system. Without a said system we will not have the capital to build sustainable homes, energy infrastructure and food systems. Economics is at the heart of it all. Since the environmental movement arose in the early 1970's it has proudly touted its achievements in winning a battle here and there but it lost the war on the one front that REALLY mattered: economics. The conservatives won. The Chicago School won and it has lead us down a path that cannot be sustained. We learnt that greed was good and short term profits were all that mattered as the free market would sort everything else out. Come the dawn of an era of peaking energy supplies and climate chaos and we had a demonstration of what many came to call "market failures".

Despite these obvious failures the market still dominates the ideology of modern Government. Chang tears this apart and asks the questions that very few even ask these days. As with "Bad Samaritans" we get a well researched slice of work but overall this is a weaker effort. The strength of "Bad Samaritans" was that it was based ...   more »

View Article  Donnachadh McCarthy "Saving the Planet without costing the Earth"
ISBN 1-904132-39-1. "Saving the Planet without costing the Earth - 500 simple steps to a greener lifestyle" by Donnachadh McCarthy was published in Fusion Press in 2004. This review is of the paperback edition which has 237 pages including an introduction, ten chapters, resources, acknowledgements. Curiously, even though chapter ten is entirely about the author the last page of the book also has a one page summary of Donnachadh's life. In fact you can read all about in again in his 2008 "Easy Eco-Auditing" books (reviewed here). We suggest you read chapter ten first as it is a good snapshot of just how accomplished Donnachadh is. He makes it all sound so easy - the true renaissance man. It seems he is good at everything he has ever done. Rising from ballet professional (at a comparatively late age) to become part of the senior executive for the UK's Liberal Democrat party. He has pioneered domestic renewable energy on his London home and when I met him in late 2010 he was enthusiastically looking for a phrase to describe HIS "carbon negative" home. On the face of it we have every reason to applaud him.

Sadly his books don't quite hit the spot. Although "Easy Eco Auditing" was a good guide about starting an eco-auditing business it proved exceptionally weak on the justification as to WHY so many of his recommendations had any worth. Our immediate impression of "Saving the Planet..." was simply that it looked starkly out of place in a post-carbon literary world now dominated by the concepts of the ecological and carbon footprinting. Donnachadh's style was to largely shoot from the hip and go with what feels right. "Saving the Planet.." actually covers some of the basic justifications missing from the later book. Given this we felt ...   more »
View Article  Donnachadh McCarthy "Easy Eco Auditing"
ISBN 978-1-85675-293-0. "Easy Eco Auditing - How to make your home and workplace planet-friendly" was written by Donnachadh McCarthy. Published by Octopus publishing in 2008. This paperback has 304 pages which includes an introduction eleven chapters, Appendices, Resources, Eco-audit form, example home eco-audit report, Index and Acknowledgements. I first met the author in person before I had any idea of his fame. I certainly had no idea that he had published two books and had such a glittering writing career. If you wish to know anything about him then it is all here. Pretty much a potted history of his life over the last twenty years. And to think he used to be a freelance ballet dancer. So I brought his two books second-hand off Amazon. Donnachadh is a nice enough chap in person but I think the term "planet-friendly" jars a little. It wouldn't have been my choice. It isn't difficult to get to hate those tired old clichés about "saving the planet" but this author falls for it on every page. This planet friendly cliché may be partly offset on page 33 (pardon the pun) by his pro-carbon-offsetting stance.

Whereas many greens vent their spleen again carbon offsetting Donnachadh sets a more reasonable tone. He writes “the fact remains that well-run carbon-offsetting schemes have a positive role to play in moving us towards a low-carbon economy.” Indeed he manages to devote over a page (34 through 35) to the “reasons to carbon offset”. He goes as far as agreeing with exactly the point made on this web site going back to 2007 and it is this “this voluntary tax on carbon emissions” doesn’t “disappear in general taxation”. It enshrines the “polluter pays” principle. In our view most of the people paying this voluntary tax are the sort of ...   more »
Recent Comments
This Month
October 2011
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31
Year Archive
Search
Search all blogs
Recent Visitors
riceimportexport - Thu 02 Feb 2012 10:45 GMT 
Macky2024 - Mon 07 Nov 2011 11:58 GMT 
allenmax - Thu 22 Sep 2011 12:17 BST 
Max123 - Wed 21 Sep 2011 07:24 BST 
HELLOOOOOOOOOOOO - Fri 16 Sep 2011 08:46 BST 
Login
User name:
Password:
Remember me